Metal Storm logo
Iced Earth - A Narrative Soundscape review



Reviewer:
2.3

89 users:
2.45
Band: Iced Earth
Album: A Narrative Soundscape
Style: Heavy metal, US power metal
Release date: January 2022


01. Dystopia (A Narrative Soundscape)
02. Declaration Day (A Narrative Soundscape)
03. Wolf (A Narrative Soundscape)
04. Dante's Inferno (A Narrative Soundscape)
05. Melancholy (A Narrative Soundscape)
06. Dracula (A Narrative Soundscape)
07. Raven Wing (A Narrative Soundscape)
08. Angels Holocaust (A Narrative Soundscape)
09. The Clouding (A Narrative Soundscape)
10. Something Wicked (A Narrative Soundscape)
11. Watching Over Me (A Narrative Soundscape)
12. Seven Headed Whore (A Narrative Soundscape)
13. Damien (A Narrative Soundscape)
14. Question Of Heaven (A Narrative Soundscape)
15. Come What May (A Narrative Soundscape)

Something wickedly bad.

Have you ever heard of the subway chinrest, the butterstick, shoe umbrellas or the USB pet rock? No? I can’t blame you. These are some examples of things that could vie for the title of the dumbest inventions ever. But lo and behold a new challenger has arrived in the form of whatever this thing is, I’ve just listened to... I’ll need more than 500 words (and some aspirins) for this...

Where to even begin with this one? Screw it, let’s start with the production. Why? Well, because it’s probably the only (relatively) positive thing I can talk about. It’s perfectly fine. Iced Earth has always had very solid to absolute great sounding productions in my opinion. This is not really any different. From what I can gather, it’s a mix of re-recorded sound bits with some files Jon probably found on his old computer. Think of things like the choir usage on “Damien” and “Question Of Heaven”. So all in all, this could be a contender for the “not quite as lazy as I expected, but still pretty damn lazy” award.

What about the performances? I mean, can you even call it a performance? It’s literally a guy reading his own song texts without any rhythm to speak of. It works as well as eating soup with a toothpick. Meanwhile, we are also removing any sort of emotion that could be implied by the song texts. “Dracula”, “Melancholy”, “A Question Of Heaven”: these songs are known by fans to have quite an emotional approach to them. I’d even argue it’s one of the reasons why fans liked Matt Barlow so much; the way he interpreted the lyrics and used his voice to deliver the lines is what makes those songs so memorable in the Iced Earth catalogue. Here it’s pure cringe. Similar to the amount of cringe you’d find in the Star Wars prequels. But not in a funny way, here it’s more the tragic type of cringe.

The only thing Jon seems to evoke with his ehm... “style”... is making everything sound like a threat. And if that wasn’t obvious enough, don’t worry, he made sure there are some audio effects sporadically layered over his voice to emphasize that. Audio effects which I can only describe as the sound of Darth Vader’s respirator breaking down. Honestly, what has happened to the original songs on this album, is next-level insulting. Like your neighbour peeing in your letterbox, only to set it on fire after that and maybe even flipping you off in the process as well.

And what’s the point of this anyway? A cash-grab? 100% certainty on that one. But even then, why go to the lengths of producing this rubbish? I mean, you could have just released this as a symphonic soundscape without the godawful narration. Or, (bear with me on this one) make a narrative soundscape of the Something Wicked saga. You know, that concept story that spans over multiple albums... But I guess taking a dump on your songs is like taking a dump in real life. You want to do it on the best possible toilet seat if you got the chance for it, so it’s only natural to do it on some of your best songs.

This can go to the deepest depths of Hell, for all I care. The “buried head first in shit” line in “Dante’s Inferno” perfectly encapsulates how I felt while listening to A Narrative Soundscape with my headphones on. And coincidentally, the line “Abandon all hope who enters here” is a fitting analogy/warning for those who are tempted to listen to this.


Rating breakdown
Performance: 2
Songwriting: 2
Originality: 2
Production: 8





Written on 20.02.2022 by You know I'm right, you just haven't realised it yet...


Comments

Comments: 21   Visited by: 491 users
20.02.2022 - 23:38
nikarg
Staff
This is one brutal review but I am sure most of us Iced Earth fans feel similarly.

Quote:
Honestly, what has happened to the original songs on this album, is next-level insulting. Like your neighbour peeing in your letterbox, only to set it on fire after that and maybe even flipping you off in the process as well.

Description of the year contender for me.
Loading...
20.02.2022 - 23:48
Rating: 1
F3ynman2000
Nocturnal Bro
Contributor
This was great to read !
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 01:14
Rating: 2
tominator
At best deranged
Contributor
Written by nikarg on 20.02.2022 at 23:38

This is one brutal review but I am sure most of us Iced Earth fans feel similarly.


Honestly, when I listened to this, I didn't know what I should be feeling at that moment. It's a bafflingly bad idea, which is then lazily executed on top of that. And to make it even worse, it's not even newly made material. It's just butchering your own work.

What was he thinking?!?!
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 06:11
Rating: 2
Lord Slothrop
Absolutely baffling release. What makes it even more baffling (to me anyway) is picturing Jon listening to these tracks and thinking, "Bad ass" or whatever, and then having the nerve to call it an Iced Earth album.

Ouch. My head hurts.
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 07:50
Rating: 2
AndyMetalFreak
A Nice Guy
Contributor
You hit the nail on the head with this review you described the exact thoughts most Iced Earth fans would of had when listening to this rubbish.
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 08:41
phanto
Lawyer fees wont pay themselves i guess
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 09:00
Given Jon raided the capitol building, I’m not surprised he released this crap
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 12:54
Skip Donahue
Account deleted
But is it as bad as Lulu?
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 13:31
Rating: 2
tominator
At best deranged
Contributor
Written by Guest on 21.02.2022 at 12:54

But is it as bad as Lulu?


I'd say yes. Because unlike that other abomination, this directly messes with some of Iced Earth's most classic songs, which is extra insulting.
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 14:35
Bad English
Tage Westerlund
Something stupid this way comes.... What a crap album..or what we can call that shit
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.

Stormtroopers of Death - ''Speak English or Die''
apos;'
[image]
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 16:38
UPDIRNS
He did this on purpose to contend with Lulu for the worst album ever made award. Maybe he lost a bet? Maybe he though "I'll make a greatest hits albums so godawful that folks will give a listen to the original releases to then be pleasantly surprised and realize how awesome these songs really are".
Or maybe he was abducted by aliens and forced to do this or be turned into a democrat? If you didn't know he's about as right wing as they come.
Loading...
21.02.2022 - 19:40
Lanthros
This is probably a product of the fact no one will work with him anymore. So he couldn't get anyone to re-record these songs for the thousandth time.
Loading...
22.02.2022 - 00:08
Lokasenna
Written by Lanthros on 21.02.2022 at 19:40

This is probably a product of the fact no one will work with him anymore. So he couldn't get anyone to re-record these songs for the thousandth time.


The best part is that this project was announced two years ago, before... everything. He didn't have to make this at all.
Loading...
22.02.2022 - 01:26
CWA
I see everyone has found their dumping ground for the day, haha. It's just a narrative soundscape guys, take it easy. Cleary John wanted an opportunity to unleash his inner thespian. Its fine for what it is. It was a interesting one time listen, but I wont be returning to it.
Loading...
23.02.2022 - 00:09
Valentin B
Iconoclast
Over the past years Jon has :

-not written any new Iced Earth material

-gone insane

-alienated himself from his bandmates, friends and fans

-put out whatever this is

As a fan of pre-this Iced Earth I feel at the very least... disappointed.
Loading...
23.02.2022 - 13:14
Bad English
Tage Westerlund
Written by Valentin B on 23.02.2022 at 00:09

Over the past years Jon has :

-not written any new Iced Earth material

-gone insane

-alienated himself from his bandmates, f


wasnt it another way around? and has he any fans left?
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.

Stormtroopers of Death - ''Speak English or Die''
apos;'
[image]
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
23.02.2022 - 13:58
Novas
I love Iced Earth, and will continue supporting the band due to Jon's riot on the DC White House here in the USA. They were my very first metal band (aside from Megadeth & Metallica) as a high school kid. And this compilation would've been way better if he edited out the narration & just left the orchestra (fan of classical music here too). So if he had released orchestra only versions as a bonus edition, it'll be perfect, on classical standards. The narration just makes it more like a story audiobook for background noise lol
Loading...
23.02.2022 - 18:03
metalbrat
Thanks for this one-hella-review, i am going to keep myself away from anywhere near to this. I dont want to see my iced earth in this way.
----
In the beginning I was made of clay. Then I bit the apple and they changed me to metal 🤘
Loading...
23.02.2022 - 18:17
Rating: 2
AndyMetalFreak
A Nice Guy
Contributor
Written by metalbrat on 23.02.2022 at 18:03

Thanks for this one-hella-review, i am going to keep myself away from anywhere near to this. I dont want to see my iced earth in this way.

I thought the same, but when listening I tried to think of it as a Jon Schaffer album, with Iced Earth sample music in the background.
Loading...
27.02.2022 - 02:33
Pablo
The only thing I can say after listening to this 'album' is: WHY?
Loading...
27.02.2022 - 14:12
Rating: 5
Karlabos
Meat and Potatos
Written by Pablo on 27.02.2022 at 02:33

The only thing I can say after listening to this 'album' is: WHY?

WHY?
Oh, yes! I love that band
----
"Aah! The cat turned into a cat!"
- Reimu Hakurei
Loading...

Hits total: 8140 | This month: 81